Events at The University of Manchester
  • University home
  • Events
  • Home
  • Exhibitions
  • Conferences
  • Lectures and seminars
  • Performances
  • Events for prospective students
  • Sustainability events
  • Family events
  • All Events

Politics - MANCEPT Research Seminar - Presented by Billy Christmas “Toward Methodological Anarchism”

image
Dates:11 February 2016
Times:16:00 - 18:00
What is it:Seminar
Organiser:School of Social Sciences
Speaker:Billy Christmas
See travel and contact information
Add to your calendar

Other events

  • In category "Seminar"
  • In group "(SoSS) Politics"
  • In group "(SoSS) Politics"
  • By School of Social Sciences

Dear all,

The next MANCEPT research seminar will be on Thursday 11 February, when our very own Billy Christmas will give a presentation titled “Toward Methodological Anarchism”. The seminar starts at 4pm in the Arthur Lewis Building 2nd floor boardroom.

The presentation will be followed by a question and answer session that will finish at around 5.30pm.

ABSTRACT: Two human frailties that can make institutions dysfunctional are self-interest and cognitive limitation. Certain institutions require the persons who constitute them to be other-regarding and well-informed, in order for the institutions to function. Inevitably, persons are not always virtuous in these regards, and institutions fail to deliver what was intended. Political philosophers are not empirical social scientists, so we do not know which institutions will supply the virtues needed for them to function. However, what we can know from the armchair is which ones demand virtue. Therefore, when we infer institutional prescriptions from our abstract ideals of justice, we ought not to prescribe institutions that depend upon virtuous persons in order for the demands of justice to be delivered (whatever these may be). Institutions which are robust perform their function even under unfavourable circumstance, for example, a lack of information or pervasive self-interest. Fragile institutions on the other hand fail to deliver what is desired – or worse, actively deliver what is not desired – when circumstances are unfavourable. As political philosophers we ought to therefore not prescribe institutions that, under unfavourable circumstances, will fail to deliver just outcomes, or actively deliver unjust outcomes. Whatever our abstract ideals, we ought to constrain the institutional prescriptions we make to robust rather than fragile ones. The state, as a monopoly, is a necessarily fragile institution. Monopolies over x privilege a certain group with being the sole supplier of x. When self-interest of cognitive failure become pervasive in a monopoly, x is not supplied, and moreover those who are in a position, morally and cognitively, to supply x are not permitted to do so. The requirement that, in lieu of doing empirical social science, for political philosophers to play their role, they most operate under a constraint that they do not prescribe institutions with supplying the demands of justice which are fragile, and this requires us to refrain from prescribing roles to the state, since the state is necessarily fragile. Call this constraint methodological anarchism.

Dr Stephanie Collins Lecturer in Political Theory Politics, School of Social Sciences University of Manchester

Email: stephanie.collins@manchester.ac.uk Phone: 0161 306 8028 Website: https://manchester.academia.edu/StephanieCollins

Speaker

Billy Christmas

Role: Speaker

Organisation: University of Manchester

Travel and Contact Information

Find event

2nd floor Boardroom 2.016 / 017
Arthur Lewis Building
Manchester

Contact event

Stephanie Collins / Val Lenferna

0161 275 4883 / 7058

val.lenferna@manchester.ac.uk

Contact us

  • +44 (0) 161 306 6000

Find us

The University of Manchester
Oxford Rd
Manchester
M13 9PL
UK

Connect with the University

  • Facebook page for The University of Manchester
  • X (formerly Twitter) page for The University of Manchester
  • YouTube page for The University of Manchester
  • Instagram page for The University of Manchester
  • TikTok page for The University of Manchester
  • LinkedIn page for The University of Manchester

  • Privacy /
  • Copyright notice /
  • Accessibility /
  • Freedom of information /
  • Charitable status /
  • Royal Charter Number: RC000797
  • Close menu
  • Home
    • Featured events
    • Today's events
    • The Whitworth events
    • Manchester Museum events
    • Jodrell Bank Discovery Centre events
    • Martin Harris Centre events
    • The John Rylands Library events
    • Exhibitions
    • Conferences
    • Lectures and seminars
    • Performances
    • Events for prospective students
    • Sustainability events
    • Family events
    • All events